EEOC rescinds criminal background check guidance: What changes – and what doesn’t – for employers
Employers may have more flexibility when evaluating applicants’ criminal histories following the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC) recent decision to rescind its longstanding guidance on criminal background checks. But before revisiting hiring policies, employers should understand an important distinction: the EEOC’s rescission changes federal enforcement guidance, not the underlying laws governing employment discrimination.
On October 29, 2026, the EEOC rescinded its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Although the decision signals a shift in the agency’s approach, employers remain subject to federal anti-discrimination laws and applicable state and local restrictions on criminal background screening.
What changed?
The EEOC’s 2012 guidance cautioned employers against automatically excluding applicants based on criminal history because such policies could disproportionately affect individuals based on race or national origin.
Instead, the guidance encouraged employers to conduct individualized assessments, considering the nature and severity of an offense, the time elapsed, and its relevance to the position.
By rescinding the guidance, the EEOC has withdrawn those recommendations. However, employers are not required to discontinue existing screening practices that comply with applicable law.
What has not changed?
Importantly, the rescission does not eliminate employers’ obligations under existing federal, state, and local laws. Several important legal obligations remain:
- Title VII still prohibits discrimination. Employers cannot use criminal background checks to intentionally discriminate based on race, national origin, or another protected characteristic. Screening policies may also face disparate impact challenges if they disproportionately exclude protected groups and cannot be justified under applicable legal standards.
- State and local restrictions still apply. Many jurisdictions independently restrict when employers may inquire about criminal history, what records they may consider, and what procedures they must follow before making adverse employment decisions. These requirements remain in effect regardless of the EEOC’s decision.
- FCRA requirements remain in effect. Employers using third-party background screening companies must continue complying with the Fair Credit Reporting Act, including applicable disclosure, authorization, and adverse action notice requirements.
What Illinois employers should know: Additional requirements still apply
For employers operating in Illinois, the rescission does not change several significant obligations under state and local law.
- Illinois’ Ban-the-Box Law. Under the Job Opportunities for Qualified Applicants Act, covered employers generally cannot inquire about an applicant’s criminal history until the applicant has been selected for an interview or, if no interview is conducted, until after a conditional offer of employment. Certain statutory exceptions apply.
- Illinois Human Rights Act. Employers generally cannot take adverse employment action based on a conviction record unless there is a substantial relationship between the conviction and the position or the employment would create an unreasonable risk to property or safety. Employers must consider specified statutory factors and follow a written notice and response process, including providing at least five business days for the individual to respond before making a final decision.
- Chicago Fair Chance Ordinance. Chicago employers must also comply with local restrictions on the use of criminal history, including applicable individualized assessment, notice, and response requirements. The ordinance also applies to current employees, meaning its requirements are not limited to the hiring process. Employers with operations in Chicago should ensure their background screening and employment decision procedures account for these additional requirements.
Bottom line for Illinois employers: Individualized assessments and procedural safeguards remain legally required in many circumstances, regardless of the EEOC’s change in guidance
What should employers do now?
The rescission does not necessarily call for immediate policy changes. Instead, employers should use this development as an opportunity to review their existing practices and confirm that their screening procedures remain legally compliant. Employers should consider three practical steps:
- Review existing screening policies. Confirm that criminal history exclusions are tied to legitimate business considerations and are appropriate for the positions at issue. Avoid blanket exclusions. Automatically disqualifying applicants based on any criminal record, regardless of the offense or its relevance to the position, can create unnecessary legal exposure.
- Maintain individualized assessments where appropriate or required. Although the EEOC has withdrawn its recommendation, individualized assessments remain an important risk-management practice and are independently required under certain state and local laws.
- Confirm compliance with state, local, and federal requirements. Employers operating across multiple jurisdictions should review their background screening procedures, adverse action notices, and hiring personnel’s training to ensure compliance with applicable laws. Ensure that those responsible for hiring understand how criminal history may be considered and that screening standards are applied consistently.
Key takeaway
The EEOC’s rescission represents a meaningful shift in federal enforcement policy, but employers should not interpret it as permission to implement unrestricted criminal background screening practices. Existing Title VII protections, state and local fair chance laws, and FCRA requirements continue to govern employers’ use of criminal history.
For employers, particularly those operating in Illinois and Chicago, the best approach is not necessarily to change existing policies, but to ensure those policies remain consistent, defensible, and compliant with applicable law. The most prudent approach is to maintain thoughtful, consistent, and legally compliant screening practices rather than make sweeping changes in response to the rescission.